Every day is opening night.

Press Contacts
Rick Miramontez / Abby Kelley / Evie Freeman / Sam Corbett
rick@omdkc.com / abby@omdkc.com / evie@omdkc.com / sam@omdkc.com
212 695 7400

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE, PLEASE

“I PUT A SPELL ON YOU:
THE 10TH ANNIVERSARY”
ANNOUNCES CAST OF BROADWAY STARS

INCLUDING
ROBYN HURDER, KRYSTA RODRIGUEZ, SEAN MCMANUS,
TAYLOR IMAN JONES, JAKE PEDERSEN, JULIA MATTISON,
KARMA JENKINS, TIM MURRAY, AND MORE

ONE NIGHT ONLY AT WEBSTER HALL
MONDAY OCTOBER 20
TICKETS ON SALE NOW

New York, NY (September 22, 2025) – Creator and executive producer Jay Armstrong Johnson (Moulin Rouge, Parade) and producers Andy Jones, Joe Hornberger, and Shannon Molly Flynn today announced the cast for the tenth anniversary celebration of “I Put a Spell on You,” a fundraiser for the Ali Forney Center on Monday, October 20^th at 8pm at Manhattan’s Webster Hall (125 E 11th St). Joining the witchery will be Tony Award nominee Robyn Hurder (SMASH, A Beautiful Noise), Krysta Rodriguez (Halston, SMASH), Sean McManus (Beetlejuice), Taylor Iman Jones (SIX), Jake Pedersen (Wicked, Parade), Tony Award nominee Julia Mattison (Death Becomes Her, Godspell), Karma Jenkins, Tim Murray, and more.

Tickets can be purchased here.

Jay Armstrong Johnson, Allison Godleski and Amanda Williams Ware return to the show as the Sanderson sisters from renowned Halloween classic, “Hocus Pocus.”  The evening’s coven will also include Natalie Hinds as Dani Dennison, Maddox Martin as Max Dennison, and Kathryn Priest as Allison, with additional casting to be announced.

I Put A Spell On You will be directed by Heath Saunders and Mack Brown. Joining the creative team is DW (Creative Director), Kyle Krueger (Director of Hair and Makeup), Andrew Garvis (Lighting Design), Connor Wang and Jaechelle Johnson (Sound Design), Sean Gorski of Hudson Theatrical (Technical Supervisor), Jackson Teeley (Music Supervisor), Michael Anthony Sylvester (Supervising Choreographer), Will Van Dyke (Music Consultant), Brian Pacelli (Video Supervision), and Andy Diaz (Props Supervision).

Caroline Pastore will serve as the Production Stage Manager and Megan Saunders will serve as Production Manager.

Also joining the production are Catriona Rubenis-Stevens as Director of Visual Performance and Jake Primmerman as Director of Cinematic Capture. Key Art Photography is by Matthew Murphy with Evan Zimmerman. Web and Graphic Design by Kat Wright. Additional creative team members and designers are to be announced.

Sponsors and donors of I Put A Spell On You include Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS, Todd & Elizabeth Donovan, Sean Cocchia, Katie Crim, Joe Hornberger, Andy Jones, Kiehl’s, Tom Schumacher, Sasaki Design, Christopher Street Financial, Javi Morgado, Mio Partners, & TEADS, Nestle Nespresso USA, Emily Vacher, The TRC Company, MISTR, Paige Price, VitaCoCo, Cason Crane, Glenn Gundersen, Stephen Mack and Brian Shaefer, with Schmackary’s, BARRY’S, The Alcone Company, J&M Special Effects, Sniffies, Production Resource Group, Matthew Murphy with MurphyMade, Jeffrey Povero, BrenBri Props, Bad Monkey Props, Marissa Schaeffer with FlySpace Physical Therapy, and Hudson Scenic Studio

A B O U T   T H E  S H O W

Jay Armstrong Johnson’s beloved Halloween benefit concert I Put a Spell on You returns to Webster Hall on Monday, October 20th at 8pm for its milestone 10th Anniversary. Inspired by Disney’s Hocus Pocus, this one-night-only spooktacular conjures show-stopping musical numbers, jaw-dropping choreography, and spine-tingling spectacle.

What began as a small cabaret has grown into a full-scale Halloween theatrical experience, raising hundreds of thousands of dollars for the Ali Forney Center, the organization supporting LGBTQIA+ youth experiencing homelessness.

Come on and Ease on Down the Witches’ Road with us! For more information and to purchase tickets, visit SpellOnYouNYC.com

“First to the Cauldron” (Early Bird GA Tickets) are available for purchase at $75 from September 22 at 10AM through September 29. After the early bird dates, tickets will rise on 9/30 to $100.

VIP Packages and Sponsorships can be found on SpellOnYouNYC.com or through Kim Rajamani at the Ali Forney Center (KRajamani@AFC.org) .

A B O U T  T H E  A L I  F O R N E Y  C E N T E R

The Ali Forney Center was founded in 2002 in memory of Ali Forney, a homeless gender-nonconforming youth who was forced to live on the streets, where they were tragically murdered. Committed to saving the lives of LGBTQ+ and at-risk young people, our mission is to protect them from the harms of homelessness and empower them with the tools needed to live independently.

A 24-hour program, The Ali Forney Center never closes its doors. We provide more than just a bed and food for those in need — from initial intake at our drop-in center to transitional housing and job readiness training, we provide homeless LGBTQ+ and at-risk youth a safe, warm, supportive environment to escape the streets.

From our leadership and staff to our youth counselors, we are all committed to helping provide stability, healing, trust and education to young adults so they can ultimately live independently.

To learn more about The Ali Forney Center and their vital work, please visit https://www.aliforneycenter.org/. @aliforneycenter

###

www.spellonyounyc.com/
www.instagram.com/iputaspellonyounyc

www.omdkc.com
www.facebook.com/omdkc
www.instagram.com/omdkc